My Story: Who Am I & What is my purpose in life?
Hi, my name is Eric and I am 32 years old. I grew up in a small town in New England but moved to California when I was 19. I currently live in the mountains of Southern California with two adorable puppies.
I was brought up in a fairly religious and conservative home. My father was a pastor in the Quaker Church for much of my childhood, and faith in God has always been a foundational element in my family life.
I have always questioned my faith. At age 12 I was punished by my Sunday school teacher for questioning the truth of the Bible (I had to sit in the car while everyone else enjoyed the church picnic). According to my teacher, my outspokenness was detrimental to the faith of my fellow students, and so, after speaking with my parents, I was moved to the adult class where my questions would be less damaging.
Throughout my twenties I continued to struggle with these same doubts and questions. It was for this reason that I chose Philosophy as my major in college.
Then, in my mid-twenties, three important changes took place that have been influential in the development of my thinking on the existence of God.
The first shift in my thinking, and what I believe was the start of my true journey into the exploration of this subject, was that I finally managed to stop feeling guilty for my doubts. For a long time I had been plagued by the feeling that I was a disappointment to my family, while at the same time being angry that I could not as easily accept the truths that everyone else seemed to consider self-evident.
I was also torn between an almost desperate need to have my thoughts validated by those around me -- the most important people in my life: my family; but I also feared being responsible for causing others to doubt their own faith. I love my family and, although I desired their validatation, I also did not want them to experience the same internal struggle that I was going through. I felt guilty every time I let my passion get too hot which inevitably resulted in conflict.
I resolved to stop discussing the subject with my family, and I believe that helped me to release the guilt I had always felt in regard to my contrary thoughts and feelings.
As I continued to consider the question of God's existence or absence, I became convinced that the answer could be found by understanding the nature of reality itself. If God had truly created both Heaven and Earth, I felt it would be impossible for Him not to leave an impression of Himself in His creation. Therefore if He did exist, evidence of that existence would be woven into the very definition of the universe.
At first this only led to further confusion and frustration, and this caused a dramatic shift in my approach to the problem. For the first time I began looking for evidence of God's absence, rather than evidence of His existence.
Let me explain. During most of my life, as I struggled with these questions, my goal had always been to prove that God did exist. The idea that there was no God was such a scary concept that unconsciously the goal of my thinking had always been to find proof of God. Now however I was able to switch my thinking and instead start with the premise that He did not exist and evaluate the evidence in that light.
Up until this point I had still considered myself a Christian struggling with his faith, but now I had to admit that I could no longer claim that affiliation. I was now an agnostic.
I reevaluated all of my previous thinking under this new view of the issue. And to my surprise, I discovered that the world around me suddenly made a great deal more sense than it had before. It was as if I had been trying to place a square peg into a round hole, and now I had picked up a round peg and was startled to find how much easier it fit.
But this feeling was still very intangible, and so, being a writer, I decided to attempt to articulate my thoughts on paper. I've been working on this thesis (off and on) for most of the last two years.
And it is from that paper that the idea for this blog was born.
As I attempted to articulate my thoughts in written form, I found the biggest obstacle to the project was my own isolation. I needed feedback from others to help me see the faults in my arguments and refine my ideas that were still too ethereal and undefined as yet.
But I could not turn to my family for this feedback, which left me without another source. Thus the creation of this blog.
I have many thoughts and ideas, but they need to be refined and expanded. To help me with that I need outside input -- other brains to help me look at things from different perspectives and views.
So that is the hope I have for this blog: To find other inquiring "souls" (no pun intended) who are willing to explore these concepts with me without defensiveness or anger.
I know the question that believers who visit this blog will be asking themselves is: Am I open to the idea that during the process of this exploration I will change my mind about God's existence and become a believer myself?
Certainly. In fact, I am hoping that contrary arguments will be brought up by others which force me to think deeper and explore ideas I hadn't considered.
So there it is. I hope that if you are reading this, you will explore this blog and participate in discussions of one of the most important questions mankind has ever considered.
Good luck and (dare I say it?) God Bless!
--Eric
15 comments:
Hi Eric, I was trying to google "When God Made You" and came across your blog. I consider myself a christian who is struggling with her faith. I questioned God so many times but no matter I tried to shake him off my life, I feel empty and lost. I keep coming back to him. Now, I am married to an agnostic man. (He used to be catholic). I love my husband, I respect his belief. I tried to answer his questions about God. I think, there's a point in our life when we tried to get away from our family. We want to live our own life. For me, God is like a family, He knows too much that I don't want Him to control me or point out my mistakes but it's ironic coz whenever I am in trouble, I always ask for His help. Just like the parable of the two sons. Now, my husband is starting to read the Bible coz he wants to know the truth, in a way, he is investigating the Bible. God bless you in your journey... your journey of life. I believe you will find the Truth.
hey, thanks for leaving a comment. and i appreciate your compassion.
i was just like you for almost 25 years. going back to God when you are in trouble is perfectly normal. but it's not proof of god's existence. when you have been brought up in the faith, it is only natural to go back to it in times of need. it's very comforting.
but it's also playing to a fantasy. it's the same reason that people buy more lottery tickets when they are in financial need. it doesn't seem to make sense until you realize that they are naturally falling back on hope -- even if it is in vain -- because for a few moments that hope helps to alleviate their stress and desperation.
but in the end it is actually more damaging. because you are actually avoiding dealing with the problems in your life yourself. it's like an alcoholic who falls off the wagon in difficult times even though it most likely just makes their situation worse.
god is like family because he is so comfortable to you. just like alcohol or drugs (or eating or whatever) is to others. we turn to that comfortableness when stressed.
but when really searching for the truth, you can't let your perceptions be clouded by your current emotional needs. that isn't true reality and won't lead to truth, only denial.
one of the main reasons that people stay in Christianity is because it represents a sense of security and validation. this is why so many christians live in a constant state of denial. they have to transition to this state in order to find any peace at all in their faith. unfortunately it often bleeds out into other areas of their life, and denial soon becomes a way of dealing with difficult situations.
i am glad that your husband is looking for the truth. and hopefully you are too. understanding the truth about god's existence is a very scary journey. and very lonely -- especially for those of us who have been brought up from childhood in the church.
i know because i've been through it. it is very hard, and there is usually no support for you because often, like myself, most of your family will be against you. it makes it especially difficult to go through it when those you usually turn to for support are not available.
but once you accept the truth, an entirely new world opens up to you and you'll be amazed at the how freeing it is to let go of that guilt and expectation. and the constant questioning and doubt that is implicit in all religions.
one thing that i would ask you is this: when you are exploring your own feelings of doubt, do you do so with an open mind toward the idea that there is no god, or are you instead constantly scrambling for proof of his existence?
your desperation comes from looking for evidence that isn't there -- or sometimes seems to be there and sometimes doesn't. this sends you in a constant circle: belief and then doubt again, depending on what's going on in your life. you'll never find truth -- or peace -- that way.
it is not easy to change your mindset, especially if you've been brought up that way. but if you stay in the mindset that you are now, there are really only two optional outcomes: either stay in this constant circle of doubt and belief, which eventually will just drive you crazy; or (and this is an even worse option) you become better and better at pushing those doubts down and not acknowledging them until you actually stop thinking for yourself at all.
in the latter option, you make the decision to believe, not because it is a rational or logical decision, but simply as a matter of emotional survival. i have seen way too many christians going this route.
my purpose here is not to destroy your faith, but only to encourage you to keep thinking. don't give in to your emotional turmoil by shutting down your brain. this is not going to enrich your life; it just makes things easier.
i hope you will continue to read my blog and leave comments. there's nothing wrong with doubt and confusion. it is by grappling with our doubts that we find truth. it is not an easy route, but it is a courageous one.
often (and I have felt this way myself) we are envious of those that seem to believe so easily. but don't feel jealous of them, instead pity them. they have given over their free will rather than experience the turmoil of doubt.
I admire you, and feel for you.I can't say that you are in my prayers, but you are in my thoughts. I really wish you and your husband the best and fortitude to continue with this difficult journey.
i hope you'll keep coming back to this blog because it's written for people like you.
this exploration doesn't always have to be a painful journey. it can be an enriching one in which you come to a much greater understanding of yourself and the universe that we inhabit.
good luck to you and thanks for posting! --e
hi eric, the way you think is exactly like my husband. it's funny coz after an email he uses "-e" also...
i haven't really questioned God's existence, just "why me?". just a year ago, i was trying to reconcile with Him and i am feeling better now. i was depressed for almost 5 years and i've never been happier. of course it's still a constant struggle but life is not always smooth sailing. there's always ups and downs. i go to this church and it's really a "cool" church. the sermon are really great. if you want to check out the sermons. here is the podcast link- http://www.journeyipod.com/ my husband like the sermons, he said it's really different from what he was used to (catholic masses). i grew up in church myself but not a pastor's kid like you. i believe that if you have strong faith in Him, you have a very different perspective in life. they never consider it a waste of their time but rather an eternal investment.
btw, you're welcome. i will definitely check your blog everyday. is it ok to pray for you??? :)
-lisa
Lisa, I understand the "why me?" thinking. I don't know in what context you are mentioning it, but for me it was always "why am I cursed with this need to THINK so much about these things? Why can't I just take it on faith, and in that find peace, like so many others?"
I don't know if you are thinking in the same vein as myself, but here is how I deal with this frustration. My feeling is that although at times these doubts and struggles can be very painful, because of them I also am blessed with the ability to experience life on a much deeper level than those who do not seem impelled to fight these internal battles. I mean no disrespect to those others. I am not asserting that I am superior to them. But in a way I am thankful because through this process I believe I come to understand myself and the world around me on a much deeper level. Because I am impelled to ask questions, to doubt my own assumptions and convictions, I am also impelled to explore areas of knowledge and consciousness that others never venture into.
If you will allow me to take a page from the Bible, remember when Jesus says to doubting Thomas how much more greatly blessed are those who believe in Him without seeing Him in the flesh? Although in this case, Jesus was speaking about those who come later, after he has left this world, I think this comment can also be applied to people like you and me. If I can paraphrase and apply the statement to the context we are speaking of here, certainly He is pleased by those who easily find their faith. But how much greater is He pleased by those who struggle and question and yet still find their faith in Him!
Now, you may find it ironic that I am quoting the Bible to support my perspective when I'm one of those who have struggled and NOT found my faith. But I have great admiration for the person who was Jesus, and although I don't believe in the infallibility of the Bible, there is still a great deal of wisdom that can be found there.
If there is a God, I believe that He would take this perspective.
I am happy that you and your husband have found a church that you enjoy. Personally I have always found church to be a waste of time. The only thing I truly found enriching was sunday school, because it involved interaction, discussion and was an atmosphere which encouraged "thinking". Church services on the other hand, involve no independent thought at all. It centers completely around worshiping an invisible and absent entity and in my view offers no positive enrichment at all. It is a purely emotional experience and leaves you with no more substance afterwards than a happy feeling and a resolution of guilt.
* * *
I have to take exception to your mention that belief in god is not a waste, but rather an "eternal investment".
This presupposes God's existence. Individuals may consider it to be an investment, but if the truth is that God does not exist, it is still a waste regardless of an individual's perception. I imagine it like someone who invests money into a mutual fund. For years he puts money into it and feels that it is an excellent investment for his future. But then, when it is time to recover that investment, he finds that the mutual fund was simply a scam the entire time, and the managers of the fund had planned from the very beginning to take the money and run.
The fact that the investor believed for years that it was a quality investment did not make it so. There was never a time when that was true, except in his own perception.
I believe that it is the same with belief in God. One may feel as though this is an investment in eternity. But if there is no eternity, then it matters not that you believed it.
I also believe that belief in God certainly gives you a different perspective on life, but I believe it is a dangerous one. It allows one to remove responsibility from oneself for moral judgments, actions and beliefs. I think this is proven by some of the unspeakable acts committed in the name of faith.
Do you think that the terrorists who flew into the Trade Centers would have done so had they not believed in an eternity after death? Certainly they would not have killed themselves so thoughtlessly except that they believed they would find reward on the other side. I can't imagine a disbeliever doing the same who is convinced he is living his one and only chance.
Of course this is an extreme example. But it illustrates how religion allows people to be relieved of the responsibility to make moral decisions for themselves. Although for most people this doesn't result in such harmful actions, it is still a very dangerous condition.
As for praying for me, please do if you would like. I used to get upset when my family would say this to me, because first of all I always felt like saying, "Why don't you do something that will really help me? Like send a check!" And also because I always imagined them praying, "Please God, help Eric from being such an idiot all the time." And that always made me angry.
But now I just consider it a compliment that someone cares enough about me (for whatever reason) to spend a few moments thinking of me. So in that context, I thank you.
I look forward to walking beside you on your journey and seeing how you transverse it. However, I am going to make a prediction which saddens me. And that is that if you eventually decide to believe in God, you will stop reading this blog, and stop thinking, and you will sacrifice depth for peace. And that will be unfortunate.
--e
I am having a church wedding since my husnabd and i had a civil wedding a year ago so we decided to split the cost of the wedding- my husband's parents and us (me and my husband). Then, was doing part-time jobs. I prayed and also told someone about my problem (my mom, who has an enourmous faith in God). I decided to give my tithe monthly since i haven;t been very faithful when it comes to giving. And it so happened that the message that Sunday was about giving so we were challenge and so I talked about it with my husband and he agreed,even though i feel like he want to complain because at first he said 10% is kinda too much but i assured him that it will be ok. And that in the Bible it mentioned about testing God, so I did. After few months, I went to visit my old employer then, he offered me bigger salary to come back and work for him, I was like "thank God!". I tool the job, then my mom offered me a job on the weekends. When we planned about the wedding, I didn;t know if we can raise the amount that we needed, I thought we're just going to borrow money from the bank. Now that my wedding is only a few months away, when i tried to do the accounting for the budget, i realized that we have more than we needed and with that I am thankful to God. Even my husband now saw how faith works. This is not the only incidence that God proved himself to me. That's my God is proven and tested to me.
You mentioned about clergy abusing children, that just show how sinful men are. Those clergy went through intensive training but they still fall short. God mentioned in the Bible that we shouldn't look up to people but rather only to Him. My pastor, once told us that no one should put him in a pedestal coz he himself fall short and that may discourage people to follow God. We think just because they share God's message every Sunday morning, that doesn't mean they can;t sin. They have a gift and that's preaching. I know their lives should be an example to everyone- that's the ideal but no one is perfect. The only good thing with those who believe in Jesus is that, we can ask for forgiveness. That's the great thing about grace.
Don't worry, I am still checking on your blog even though I disagree to some of it- maybe most of it. hehehe... By the way, I grew up in church, I accepted God when I was only 7- I matured really early. But then I didn't grasp the Word of God then. I see people in my church that are very complacent and act very unchristianly. But that didn't discourage my faith though I was like a Sunday christian. Not until I moved out for college and I was involved in this college ministry- Navigators. They are the best. I can say that it helped me a lot and it change some of the things I believed in the past example- I once told not to eat animals blood coz it's a sin, now. pork blood is my favorite. When people asked me about my religion, then they said that there are certain things I can;t do because of my religion. I certainly can do anything.
Have a nice day!!!
Check out the podcast website I gave you, maybe it will answer some of your questions.
Regarding your family? If they call you idiot, that means they are not being a christian. Do you ask your family for money? Coz if you really need help you should tell them, coz if you just keep it to yourself it won't help. Maybe, the enemy is toying with your mind.
Have a nice day!
-Lisa
Lisa - So good to hear from you. I've been without internet for a week or so (can you believe they refuse you service when you can't pay?), so I'm a little late replying to you. In fact, it was my parents who came through for me just when I needed it. My bank account had dropped below zero, and out of the blue my dad sent me a check for some work I've been doing on a website he wants to make which provides a very different perspective on God than this one.. I should also point out that I did not pray for this, nor asked for it. I suspect it was actually because my parents love me and want to help me. And partly a result of the fact that I've been using my unemployment time helping him with his website.
I guess you'd say I'm just lucky, but not blessed.
I am very happy about the good things that are happening in your life. I certainly am not one to take for granted the blessings we receive in life, I just think it's silly to attribute such things to God.
I'm going to be posting an article on prayer in the next few weeks, but let me address it briefly here. In attributing the recent blessings in your life to God or prayer, you are basically assuming causation from what is simply a correlation. The difference is that a causation is an action which produces a specific result -- every time. An action is performed and yields a result.
In a situation of causation, you can remove all other factors and you will still produce the same result. Because there is a direct relationship between an action and the resulting product. Thus causation.
A corellation on the other hand, is when you perceive a result and associate it with a prior event although there is no direct or predictable relationship between them.
For example, it is a fact that we hear thunder about four seconds after seeing a lightning flash. Now, if we didn't understand that sound and light travel at different speeds, it would be easy to assume that the lightning was causing the thunder.
This is, of course, incorrect, as we know by witnessing thunder but no lightning and vice versa.
Ah, you say, but when I pray I am more likely to experience good things in return, and that proves it!
Well, no, all you are proving is that by praying you are creating a situation of likelihood. In other words the act of prayer creates a situation where success is more likely.
By constantly keeping your goal in mind by praying, you are unconsciously encouraging yourself to make decisions and take advantage of opportunities that will bring you closer to your goal.
Focus is the key to success, whether you accomplish this by fervently praying every day, or putting a picture of your dream house on your desk so you are reminded of your desire on a consistent basis.
This is the only explanation for why Mother Theresa touch so many lives, and so has Osama Bin Laden.
Consider for a moment the success of both Mother Theresa and Osama Bin Laden to affect the lives of thousands of people. Their goals in affecting those lives may have been very different, and yet they both have been very effective in that goal.
To explain the success of these very different goals, we either attribute it to the fact that both of them spent time praying to God for their success as the reason... or we have to look for some other commonality.
The only other thing they both have in common is their focus and determination to achieve their goals.
***
I think you slightly misunderstood me when I pointed out the evils done by the church and those purporting to be believers.
I have no doubt that all men (and women) are capable of evil. But to me this is just more evidence for the absence of God.
If God were a real, tangible influence in our lives, and the source of all good in the universe, then we should see a predictable increase of good qualities in believers and a decrease of evil in them.
But according to the evidence this isn't so. Believers are capable of just as much evil as unbelievers. And inversely, unbelievers are just as capable of good.
Two other quick points:
First, excusing priests of their actions because "all men are sinful" just doesn't fly for me.
Priests should spend more time with God, simply as a result of their chosen profession, so that should result in a greater capacity for good and less for evil. Obviously, this isn't the case.
Secondly, a priest is a good and god-like person by definition -- it is what makes him a priest. Not only does he claim such a status, but he's paid to be that way. In a way it's his job.
If you hired an artist to come paint a mural on the wall, and coming home you find he only managed stick figures and hand-prints, would you hire him again?
Finally, my issue is with the church's response to this. And although it is easy to pick on the Catholic Church because they make themselves such an easy target, this could be applied to most religious institutions.
These institutions, which should be a pillar example of God's character, are more interested in the semblance of goodness than actual goodness.
The only proof available in determining the presence of something which cannot be "seen" using our available senses is to observe its influence in the world around us. This is how scientists identify black holes, dark matter and even the presence of gravity.
This does not seem to apply to God. There is no direct, predictable evidence of divine influence.
Therefore we can conclude that there is no influence.
I hope that is understandable.
I can tell from your posts that you are a good and compassionate person. You are likely someone I would be pleased to call a friend.
But would you be any less so if there was no God? Is your goodness a result of the presence of God, or is it an inherent quality that is part of your own identity.
Keep reading, and keep thinking and see you soon!
--eric
Hey :) I was going to subscribe... but I'm afraid of giving out my personal address - it's a new one and is so far free of unwanted e-mails. But I just thought I'd tell you I hadn't forgotten about your blog and I'll be reading it :) Take care!
this isn't the rebekah i know, is it? i think your email is safe. i certainly don't give it out to anyone, and i believe feedburner (my RSS agent) has a very strict privacy policy. in fact, if i hear of them spamming emails please let me know -- i'll find another service. anyway, thanks for stopping in and i'll talk to you soon.
--e
It is :) As in Rebekah Ann A... Sorry for the confusion!
[B]NZBsRus.com[/B]
Dismiss Idle Downloads Using NZB Files You Can Easily Find High Quality Movies, Games, MP3s, Software & Download Them at Dashing Rates
[URL=http://www.nzbsrus.com][B]Newsgroup Search[/B][/URL]
It isn't hard at all to start making money online in the underground world of [URL=http://www.www.blackhatmoneymaker.com]blackhat backlinks[/URL], Don’t feel silly if you haven’t heard of it before. Blackhat marketing uses not-so-popular or misunderstood methods to build an income online.
top [url=http://www.001casino.com/]001casino.com[/url] coincide the latest [url=http://www.casinolasvegass.com/]free casino[/url] autonomous no set aside bonus at the leading [url=http://www.baywatchcasino.com/]casino online
[/url].
We аrе a grοup of volunteеrs anԁ oρenіng a new ѕcheme in our
cοmmunity. Your site provided us ωith vаluаble info tο wоrk on.
You've done an impressive job and our entire community will be thankful to you.
Here is my weblog :: Micro Stakes Promotions
Hi there! I κnοw this іs someωhat οff topic but I was ωοndeгing whiсh blοg
ρlatform are you using for this site?
I'm getting tired of Wordpress because I've had issues with haсkers and І'm looking at options for another platform. I would be great if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.
Also visit my web-site - MintedPoker Promotions
I am not suгe where you are gettіng your informatіon, but gгeat tοpіс.
I needѕ tο spend ѕomе tіme learnіng much more or understanding more.
Τhanks for exсеllent info I waѕ looking
for this info for my mission.
Feel free to surf to mу wеb-ѕite: 888 Poker Offer ()
Post a Comment